The 5 best eCRF software options for medical device studies
Most eCRF demos tend to end the same way. A clean form fills in on screen, an edit check fires right on cue, and someone says the build will take "a couple of weeks."
Then the first protocol amendment pops up 4 months in, and that's when you find out what the software is really like.
So why don't we just start with that criteria. We'll talk about the actual vendors in a bit, and judge them against how medical device studies actually run: small feasibility cohorts, pivotal investigations under ISO 14155 and post-market clinical follow-up (PMCF) studies under the EU Medical Device Regulation (MDR).
If you're still getting oriented on what an electronic case report form (eCRF) is and how it relates to the EDC system around it, start with our essential guide to eCRFs for medical devices. For this assessment, we'll assume you know something about eCRFs and are interested in choosing which one works best for your situation.
5 criteria for choosing eCRF software
1. Design flexibility
Device studies vary more than drug trials do. A 15-subject feasibility study, a multicenter pivotal investigation and a PMCF registry can share one device and still need different visit schedules, endpoints and adverse event pathways.
Look for a form builder that handles per-procedure observations, device deficiency reporting and repeating forms without custom code. If possible, give the prospective vendor an actual form from your protocol and see if they'll build it live.
The form-level decisions get their own treatment in our eCRF design best practices post, and the full build sequence is in how to design an eCRF for medical device studies.
2. Edit checks and validation logic
Data quality gets won or lost here. A good system catches an impossible date or an out-of-range value at entry, while the coordinator still has the source document in hand.
Can rules reference fields on other forms? Do queries fire automatically when a check fails? And can someone on your team write and test a rule, or does every change route through the vendor's services group?
3. Site usability and training burden
Site staff enter data during or right after a procedure, where data collection comes second to patient care. Every extra click shows up later as a query.
Time a new coordinator completing a visit form with no help. An eCRF that needs a 90-minute training session per site gets expensive fast across 20 sites and a couple of rounds of staff turnover.
4. ISO 14155 and Part 11 support
ISO 14155:2020 sets good clinical practice for clinical investigations of medical devices, and 21 CFR Part 11 governs electronic records and signatures in FDA-regulated studies.
Pay attention to how the vendor uses the word "ready." A Part 11-ready system meets the technical requirements, but your people, procedures and documentation still have to do their part. Ask who owns the validation package, what's in it and whether your auditors can see it.
5. Build and change turnaround
Two areas that you will want to ask about are how many days it takes to go from final protocol to go-live, and how many days it takes to go from an approved amendment to a revised eCRF in production.
How long it takes to go from approved amendment to revised eCRF is critical. Amendments are routine in device work, and a six-week change cycle can stall enrollment at every site you have.
BONUS RESOURCE: Download the free eCRF template for clinical investigations and PMCF studies and document your form specifications before you start calling vendors.
The 5 best eCRF tools for medical device studies
1. REDCap: best for investigator-led studies at academic sites
REDCap started at Vanderbilt University in 2004 and now runs at more than 7,200 institutions in 156 countries. Non-profit, academic and government organizations license it at no cost through the REDCap Consortium.
For an investigator-initiated study at a university hospital, it's hard to beat. Research staff often know it already, the institution already hosts it, and branching logic, edit checks, longitudinal visit schedules and surveys come standard.
Compliance takes more assembly. REDCap is Part 11-ready, so the software meets the technical specs, and each institution still validates its own instance and maintains the procedures around it. A National Center for Advancing Translational Sciences (NCATS) working group published an implementation guide for that issue, and 259 people from 164 institutions accessed it within six months.
There are two limits for device sponsors, however. A commercial manufacturer can't buy a REDCap license, since the consortium licenses only to non-profit members. And if a sponsor plans to count investigator-led data toward PMCF, someone still has to confirm that study conforms to ISO 14155.
2. Greenlight Guru Clinical: best for sponsor-run device studies from feasibility to PMCF
Greenlight Guru Clinical, formerly SMART-TRIAL, was built for medical device and diagnostics studies, with pre-market investigations, PMCF studies, registries and long-term follow-up all running in one system.
Against the criteria, the form builder ships with 17 pre-validated question types, which cuts the time a team spends validating question design. Rules come in three types (validation, show, and process), which covers most edit-check needs without code. The platform comes pre-validated against FDA, EU and ISO 14155:2020 requirements, and study setup typically takes two to three weeks.
It is a commercial subscription, so an academic investigator with institutional REDCap access may have little reason to switch. It's also narrower by design. A sponsor running mostly pharmaceutical trials with one device study on the side may find a pharma-first platform fits its existing processes better.
3. OpenClinica: best for teams with in-house IT that want open source
OpenClinica comes in two editions. Community is free, open source and self-hosted. The commercial edition is cloud-hosted and validated, comes with a compliance team, and supports 21 CFR Part 11, ICH GCP, EU Annex 11, HIPAA and GDPR.
Community edition suits a group with a data manager, a server and the appetite to own validation. OpenClinica is candid about the trade-off. The free version is unvalidated and unsupported, and the company notes that self-hosting, validation and add-on modules can end up costing more than its subscription.
For a device sponsor, the commercial edition is the realistic path, with cross-form checks and queries that fire automatically on unresolved edit checks. Before you sign, ask to see a device deficiency form already built in the system.
4. Climedo: best for EU-focused PMCF studies and registries
Climedo is a German EDC vendor that markets directly to device manufacturers running clinical investigations, PMCF studies, registries and surveys under EU MDR, including software as a medical device (SaMD). Its eCRF, eCOA/ePRO and eSurvey modules combine as needed, and the company says the system is audited against ICH GCP, GAMP 5, 21 CFR Part 11 and EU GMP Annex 11.
The survey module earns its place for PMCF work. Plenty of PMCF activities rely on structured surveys of users and patients, and Climedo runs those standalone or alongside eCRF data.
Where to probe: Climedo's public material leans heavily on EU MDR use cases. A U.S. sponsor planning an investigational device exemption (IDE) study should ask for examples of FDA-facing work and review the validation documentation early.
5. Medidata Rave EDC: best for large multinational pivotal programs
Medidata Rave is the incumbent. Medidata says Rave has supported more than 35,000 studies, including more than 900 medical device trials, and it connects to eConsent, eCOA, randomization and imaging on one platform.
For a big pivotal program across several countries, or a sponsor whose contract research organization (CRO) already standardizes on Medidata, that depth counts. Medidata also sells Rave Lite, a scaled-down version aimed at device feasibility and post-market studies.
The trade-off is weight. Rave grew up in pharmaceutical development, and fitting a pharma data model to device-specific forms takes design and validation work (the cost of that adaptation is laid out in what you give up when your device study runs on a pharma EDC). For a 30-patient feasibility study, I reckon most of that horsepower sits in the garage.
BONUS RESOURCE: Watch the webinar on what an EDC built for device studies gives you, from ISO 14155 requirements to handling feasibility through PMCF without a custom build each time.
How to pick from these five
Map the study before you map the market. Who's the sponsor, where are the sites, how many amendments do you expect, and which regulator reads the final report?
Then put every finalist through the same test. Hand each one a real form from your protocol, a real amendment and a site coordinator who has never seen the system, and see how long each one takes.
Write your specifications before you do anything. The eCRF template for electronic data capture post shows how to document them so each vendor builds against the same spec.
Whichever tool wins that test on your study is the right answer for you, even if it turns out to be a free one from a university in Nashville.
P.S. Remember that "couple of weeks" from the demo? Ask what it turns into after the first amendment.
Keep reading
If you're building out your eCRF evaluation, these guides go deeper on the pieces:
- The essential guide to eCRF for medical devices
- eCRF design best practices for medical device clinical investigations
- How to design an eCRF for medical device studies
- eCRF template for clinical investigations and PMCF studies
- How to choose an EDC system for medical device clinical investigations
- Post-market clinical follow-up under EU MDR
Etienne Nichols is the Head of Industry Insights & Education at Greenlight Guru. As a Mechanical Engineer and Medical Device Guru, he specializes in simplifying complex ideas, teaching system integration, and connecting industry leaders. While hosting the Global Medical Device Podcast, Etienne has led over 200...
Get your free PDF
Ultimate Guide to Selecting the Ideal PMCF Activity
.png?width=250&height=324&name=Selecting%20the%20Ideal%20PMCF%20Activity%20(cover).png)



